Recently Talal Toukan, a student of mine in Art History, and an actor in my plays, and all-around stupendous young man, won the Declamation Contest for the school. He based his talk on a painting we had studied in class, but more importantly, he put his own spin on this painting and what it should mean to his peers. I asked Talal if he minded if I had a copy of his speech and posted it on my blog. Give this a read and see if you don't feel better about the future of the world in the hands of some of our youth!
I saw a
painting recently called Aristotle Contemplating a Bust of Homer. It is by a
man called Rembrandt. In it a bearded Aristotle grasps a marble bust of Homer,
thinking, while a gold chain clings to his upper body. On this chain hangs a
medallion of his student Alexander the Great. He is dressed
in 17th century attire, with long hanging sleeves and a big circular
hat characteristic of the artist's era. Although he is surrounded by darkness,
which fills up most of the canvas, his face is covered by light from an unseen
window to the upper left. As for the subject matter, Aristotle is thinking of
what the future has to hold for him. Will he be like the person whose bust he
holds, a poet and artist. Or will he be like the person whose medallion he
wears, a ruthless but great leader.
In 1961
the painting sold for $2.3 million dollars. To me it's priceless and the reason
for that is simple. It's because it's is a portrait of me. When I look at it, it
makes me Aristotle. He may look
older in the painting but Aristotle is a senior, and I'm sure of it. He has just
completed his college applications and started his second term. Besides his
fatal case of senoritis, he has been confronted with a question we all faced
this year: What defines me?
Aristotle is thinking about how some of us as seniors have
tried to answer it simply. "We are older therefore we get to be in charge. We
get to be destructive, who cares we'll be gone next year anyway. We get to laze
around and forget about our grades and forget about our lives because we've been
thinking about them for so long."
But I
think Aristotle would beg to differ. He would say that, yes, we do get to forget
about our grades, but not for our own comfort. We get to forget about our grades
because we realize that the numbers that we thought defined us no longer apply.
A 94 percent or a B- doesn't mean anything to us anymore. Instead we have to
choose how to judge our success. We have to remember life because we neglected
it on all those nights when we we're up until two o'clock in the morning working
on an essay or a lab report thinking solely of our GPAs.
So
let's remember life like Aristotle does. Does it make sense to define ourselves
by what universities we got in to? I don’t think so. I think this admissions
process only blinds us. You should be the one who chooses what university you
get into, not vice-versa. Regardless of how difficult it is to answer the
question "Who am I?" you should be the one to answer it, not a room full of
people looking at your SAT scores. We're artworks not statistics.
So who
do you want to be? Rembrandt's Aristotle was faced with the choice of becoming
an isolated artist or a great world leader. Should we seek fame, fortune or,
knowledge. Pleasure or depth. Mind or matter.
Well
it's really up to each of us to answer that question individually. For now all I
know is that we need to return what we took, what we took for granted: King's.
Let's
go back to the painting for a second. Aristotle was an ingenious Ancient Greek
philosopher as I'm sure a lot of you know. However, we only know as much as we
know about him because of Islamic scholars. It was Al-Kindi, Ibn Rushd and Ibn
Sina among others who originally translated the philosopher's ancient Greek
works into Arabic which were then translated into Latin just in time to fuel a
Renaissance in Florence. But don't worry I'm not going to follow in the
footsteps of speakers we've heard before. I'm not going to reminisce over times
when Arabs ruled the world. And I'm certainly not going to tell you off for all
the misery Arabs have gone through since our glory days. We're only teenagers
after all.
All we
know is that Arabs haven't been doing really well lately, and we shouldn't be
ashamed of that. Every people have their ups and downs, and now we're down. I
would even take it to the extent of saying that we're going through a Medieval
Age. Religious extremism and dictatorships have eaten us from the inside out.
Our culture is a broken mirror lying on the floor. You pick up a piece and only
see a fragment of your identity.
But I'm
not upset about that. In fact, if I were thinking selfishly I would be happy
about it. I mean, look at us; we're the thinkers, the exceptions. And the great
thing about exceptions is that they break the rules. We get to break the
misconceptions and spread our progressive mentality.
And I
love King's Academy for that. King's is my
intellectual sanctuary. It's a breeding ground for ideas. It's a place where you
can talk about whatever you want. You don't think God exists, ok then let's
discuss it. You think homosexuality's a sin, we'll I'm sure that can be debated.
And my respect for King's doesn't stop there. You want to know what I really
think? I think King's could possibly give birth to another Arab golden age.
But
some of you dislike King's and you dislike me for talking about it in such a
grand way so let me share my crazy vision of the Middle East with you. In the
future, King's continues to produce excellent students who go abroad to study.
After several years those students come back and start donating to King's. Some
of them might even open up schools that match King's. Those schools then begin
to compete to see who has the best writers, the best mathematicians, the best
poets, the best soccer players. And it isn't even about which one sends off more
students to Harvard. It's about which school enriches their students' minds
more. Anyway, that wave of students goes to study abroad, and possibly at
regional universities King's alumni opened, and they too come back. Then they
become professional mathematicians, artists, poets, etc. and they begin to
compete to see who can produce the most intellectually stimulating material. And
there you have it another Arab golden age.
But
that's ridiculous isn't it? What about all the problems? What about the economy?
What about the politics? Who in their right minds would come back to this
wasteland of a country? Who would donate to King's after the years of torture it
put us through?
We'll
be graduating soon seniors. And as we near the end of the year they'll be
putting together a senior video and they'll come up to each of us and ask:
"Where will you be ten years from now?" So let me tell you where you'll be and
save you some time. You'll be in your office on top of a skyscraper named after
your billion dollar company. You'll be in New York at the United Nations
prosecuting an international criminal in front of hundreds of people. Or you'll
be in London acting in a play that is sold out five days a week, forty weeks a
year.
But
just know that, whether your secretary leaves your room for a second to grab the
latest market predictions, or whether you're driving home from the UN with less
hope for the world in your heart than you had the day before, or the curtains
close after your big monologue and the applause dies down, you're going to be
alone. And for a brief moment you won't have anything to think about. So
naturally, your brain will pull out a file you stowed away from the past, a
question you haven't thought of since you're senior year: What defines me? Am I
Alexander or Homer? You're neither; you're Aristotle again, thinking. But the
question reminds you of how you shared the problem with an entire class. And for
a second you remember that beautiful school half-way across the world and you
think to yourself: What did I do to contribute to it? How did I help it realize
its vision?
Wow. Thank you Talal...
No comments:
Post a Comment